SEO Anchors

Why You Don’t Rank Keywords with Anchors Anymore: The Search Intent Revolution

Photo of author

By seoshouter

The SEO world has undergone a dramatic shift.

Gone are the days when stuffing keywords into anchor texts would propel your page to the top of the SERPs.

If you’re still stuck in the mindset of “ranking keywords with links,” it’s time for a wake-up call.

This in-depth guide will explain why Google’s algorithms have moved far beyond keywords and focus instead on search intent and user-centric strategies.

Plus, you’ll learn how to adapt and thrive in this modern SEO landscape.

The Death of Keyword-Centric SEO

What Happened to Keywords?

Once upon a time, SEO was simple.

If you wanted to rank for “best toasters,” you stuffed your page with the phrase and built backlinks with the same anchor text.

But Google evolved. Starting with the Hummingbird update in 2013, keywords began taking a backseat.

The focus shifted from exact keyword matches to user intent.

From Keywords to Search Queries

Google no longer thinks in terms of keywords.

Instead, it interprets search queries—what users type in—and connects them to their underlying user intents.

Here’s the key difference:

  • Keywords: Static phrases that match content word-for-word.
  • Search Queries: Dynamic inputs interpreted by Google to understand user goals.

Understanding Search Intent

What Is Search Intent?

Search intent (or user intent) refers to the reason behind a query.

Google now maps queries to specific intents, prioritizing relevance over exact keyword matches.

This means SEO isn’t just about targeting phrases but aligning your content with what users want.

Three Layers of Intent

  1. Primary Intent: The user’s main goal (e.g., “buy backlinks”).
  2. Secondary Intent: Sub-questions or related information they might also seek (e.g., “how much do backlinks cost?”).
  3. Tertiary Intent: Broader, tangentially related topics they might explore later (e.g., “do backlinks still work in 2024?”).

Addressing these layers holistically helps build topical authority and improves your rankings.

Why Anchors No Longer Rank Keywords

The Old Way vs. The New Way

In the past, links with exact-match anchor texts like “best toaster” were enough to rank a page for that keyword.

Today, Google uses machine learning embeddings to evaluate the context surrounding anchors and the intent of linked pages.

  • Old System: Keyword = Ranking.
  • New System: Context + Intent = Ranking.

Dangers of Over-Optimized Anchors

  • Repeating exact anchors can trigger penalties for being unnatural.
  • Over-reliance on anchors ignores the need for contextual relevance, which Google prioritizes.

Building Topical Authority with Intent Mapping

To succeed in SEO today, you need to move beyond individual keywords and think about your site as a topical graph.

This involves creating interconnected content that covers all layers of user intent.

Steps to Build a Topical Graph

  1. Identify Intents:
    • Conduct intent-focused research to understand primary, secondary, and tertiary intents for your audience.
  2. Create Content for Each Intent:
    • Primary intent: Directly address the main query.
    • Secondary intent: Cover subtopics within the same article.
    • Tertiary intent: Link to related content for deeper exploration.
  3. Strategically Interlink Articles:
    • Use internal links to connect related content, reinforcing your site’s topical authority.

Example: A guide on “search intent” could link to:

  • Primary intent: “What is search intent?”
  • Secondary intent: “Types of search intent.”
  • Tertiary intent: “How to create a keyword research plan with intent.”

The Role of Contextual Anchors

Crafting Smart Anchors

Instead of exact matches, focus on creating contextually relevant anchors. For example:

  • “Learn more about search intent.”
  • “This guide explains user intent.”
  • “Here’s a deep dive into intent-based SEO.”

These phrases provide meaning and relevance without over-optimizing.

Google now understands the semantic context of anchors, so meaningful phrases outperform robotic, repetitive links.

Proof of Contextual Intelligence

Google’s AI is so advanced that it can rank a page based on seemingly random, context-rich phrases like “search intent finally clicked.”

This proves that thoughtful anchors are more effective than exact-match ones.

Opportunities in Modern SEO

Identifying Content Gaps

  • Analyze competitors’ rankings to uncover missing topics in the SERPs.
  • Look for queries with varied results, indicating multiple user intents that aren’t fully satisfied.

Expand Your Topical Coverage

  • Write in-depth guides to fill gaps.
  • Address primary, secondary, and tertiary intents to cover topics comprehensively.

Practical Application: How to Win at SEO in 2024 and Beyond

  1. Forget Keywords, Focus on Intent:
    Your keyword research should now be search intent research. Group queries by intent and prioritize user satisfaction over keyword density.
  2. Use Anchors Strategically:
    • Avoid repeating exact-match anchors.
    • Use meaningful, varied phrases that reflect the context of the linked content.
  3. Build a Topical Graph:
    • Create clusters of content that interlink to establish authority in your niche.
  4. Leverage Context Over Relevance:
    • For backlinks, the context of the linking article matters more than the site’s overall relevance.
  5. Adapt and Evolve:
    • Stay updated on Google’s evolving algorithm.
    • Continuously refine your strategies based on what works.

The Future of SEO

Google’s reliance on machine learning and user-centric algorithms has redefined how content ranks.

To thrive, SEOs must embrace search intent, prioritize topical relevance, and move away from outdated practices like over-optimized anchors.

By aligning with user needs and building contextual relationships, you can achieve lasting success in the ever-changing SEO landscape.

Image source: https://www.freepik.com/